Restoring Justice: Citizenship Through Article 116 (2) Of The German Basic Law

[Editor2]

The scars left by National Socialist persecution in Germany are deep and enduring. Among the many injustices inflicted during that dark era, the systematic revocation of German citizenship for political, racial, and religious reasons stands as a profound violation of human rights. To address these wrongs, the German Basic Law, through Article 116 (2), offers victims of persecution and their descendants an opportunity to reclaim their citizenship, symbolizing redress and recognition.

This article explores the historical and legal context of Article 116 (2), the criteria for eligibility, and how descendants of victims may navigate the pathway to restitution.

---

Article 116 (2) of the Basic Law: A Legal Framework for Restitution​

The Provision​

Article 116 (2) of the German Basic Law states:

“Former German citizens, who between January 30, 1933, and May 8, 1945, were deprived of their citizenship on political, racial, or religious grounds, and their descendants, shall on application have their citizenship restored.”

This legal framework ensures that victims of Nazi persecution and their descendants have a legally guaranteed right to re-naturalisation, provided specific criteria are met. The law aims to reverse some of the effects of mass disenfranchisement enacted during the Nazi regime.

Entitlement Naturalisation​

The regulation falls under "entitlement naturalisation," meaning eligible individuals are not merely applying for naturalisation—they have a legal right to it if they meet the requirements. This distinction simplifies the process compared to other naturalisation avenues.

---

Historical Context: Systematic Denationalisation Under the Nazi Regime​

During the National Socialist dictatorship, citizenship became a tool of exclusion and persecution. Two main legal instruments facilitated the revocation of German citizenship during this period:

1. Individual Revocation (1933):
   Under the "Law on the Revocation of Naturalization and the Withdrawal of German Citizenship," individuals deemed “undesirable” by the Nazi regime were stripped of citizenship. This included political opponents, refugees, and ethnic minorities.
2. Collective Revocation (1941):
   The "Eleventh Ordinance to the Reich Citizenship Act" automatically stripped all Jews residing abroad of their German citizenship. This measure targeted those who had fled persecution, further isolating them from legal protections.

These laws were part of the broader systemic disenfranchisement and persecution of minorities, leaving countless families stateless.

---

Criteria for Re-Naturalisation​

Eligibility Requirements​

• Loss of Citizenship: Individuals who lost their German citizenship between January 30, 1933, and May 8, 1945, due to persecution on political, racial, or religious grounds are eligible.
• Descendants: Direct descendants of individuals who suffered citizenship revocation during this period may also apply for restoration.

Exceptions​

• Individuals who returned to Germany after 1945 and met specific criteria may retain continuous citizenship.
• Those who regained citizenship under Article 116 (2) but later renounced it are ineligible for re-naturalisation under this provision.

---

Supplementary Regulation: Section 15 of the Citizenship Act​

In 2021, amendments to the Citizenship Act introduced Section 15, broadening eligibility for victims of Nazi persecution and their descendants who do not qualify under Article 116 (2). This regulation specifically addresses cases where:

• Citizenship was voluntarily relinquished before February 26, 1955.
• Applicants were denied naturalisation despite filing.
• Individuals lost habitual residence in Germany for various reasons.

Section 15 thus complements Article 116 (2), offering a pathway to redress for a wider range of victims and descendants.

---

Practical Implications and Legacy​

Article 116 (2) and Section 15 embody Germany’s commitment to addressing historical wrongs. They not only restore citizenship but also serve as a symbolic acknowledgment of the injustices endured. For descendants of victims, these laws provide a chance to reconnect with their heritage, benefit from EU citizenship, and reclaim a part of their family’s lost identity.

---

Pros and Cons Summary​

Pros:

• Legal Guarantee: Entitlement naturalisation ensures a straightforward process for eligible individuals.
• Symbolic Restitution: The laws acknowledge and aim to rectify historical injustices.
• Generational Scope: Descendants are also eligible, ensuring broad redress for affected families.
• Expanded Eligibility: Section 15 accommodates individuals excluded from Article 116 (2).

Cons:

• Complex Documentation: Applicants must provide substantial evidence of persecution or citizenship loss.
• Exclusions Apply: Certain cases, such as those involving renunciation, are not covered.
• Time-Consuming: The application process, while clear, may involve significant time and bureaucratic hurdles.

Article 116 (2) and related regulations reflect Germany’s effort to heal historical wounds while strengthening its legal and moral foundations. They offer not just citizenship but also justice and recognition for generations affected by one of history’s gravest chapters.

 

[adamhholmes]

The legal framework under Article 116 (2) is quite clear—if your ancestors lost German citizenship due to Nazi persecution, you have the right to reclaim it. It’s not discretionary like other naturalization processes. However, proving lineage and citizenship loss can be tricky, especially for families that fled and lost documentation.

 

[nickdev]

The legal framework under Article 116 (2) is quite clear—if your ancestors lost German citizenship due to Nazi persecution, you have the right to reclaim it. It’s not discretionary like other naturalization processes. However, proving lineage and citizenship loss can be tricky, especially for families that fled and lost documentation.

So, does this mean that if my great-grandfather lost his citizenship in the 1930s, I can apply for a German passport today? What kind of proof would I need?

 

[mattm]

So, does this mean that if my great-grandfather lost his citizenship in the 1930s, I can apply for a German passport today? What kind of proof would I need?

Yes, you can apply! I actually went through this process. You’ll need birth certificates, naturalization records (if applicable), and proof that your ancestor was stripped of citizenship under Nazi laws. In some cases, German archives have these records, but it really depends on individual circumstances.

 

[cmarchan]

WOW dis iz GRAET!!! I NEVR knEW U cud get GErmAn PASSpOrt lIkE DIS!! but wut about da ppl who renOUNCeD it nOw tHey cAN’t geT iT baCk??

 

[hannah_solo]

Right?? Germany’s like, “Here’s your citizenship back,” and some people are like, “Nah, I gave it up, I’m good.” Imagine explaining that to your ancestors. “Hey great-grandpa, thanks for surviving, but I like my current passport better.”

 

[tommy_lee]

This reminds me of post-WWII discussions where many German Jews chose not to return due to trauma. While Article 116 (2) is a noble attempt at reparation, it’s interesting that some descendants don’t want to claim it. History has a strange way of coming full circle.